“Everyone Will Work It Out Over Thanksgiving” — Kimberly Perry Doesn’t Say Much About Her Brother Neil Claiming He Was Fired From The Band

Her side of the story… kind of.

The Band Perry announced they were taking a hiatus back in 2023, before hitting the road this year following a 2025 relaunch… sort of. The band responsible for hits like “If I Die Young,” “You Lie,” and “Better Dig Two” was originally made up of siblings Kimberly, Reid and Neil Perry, but now consists of Kimberly and her husband, Johnny Castello. And apparently the lineup change wasn’t entirely without drama.

If you recall, Kimberly has been on a bit of a press tour since the return announcement, most notably going on the likes of Rolling Stone and Bobby Bones’ podcasts over the past year. During these interviews, she’d claim that both brothers were completely on board with the current state of the band.

In fact, she’d tell Rolling Stone that both of them gave her their blessing to continue The Band Perry without them:

“Yeah, absolutely. I think they are very interested in The Band Perry getting landed as well. We are so proud of the past that we shared, and I think it’s just been about where does it go in the future. This was really my family band in the living room before anything else…

It’s just so cool to feel that love and support and to know that, ‘Hey guys, I’ve got this. Everything that we built was so magical and so beautiful. And I’m gonna go land this with the same integrity that we started it with.’ And of course, there’s always an open seat for a brother if they ever want to tour.”

According to Neil, however, that’s not the real story. In fact, he seems to be claiming that it’s a flat out lie.

A few months ago, he took to Instagram to claim that he had been kicked out of the family band by his sister and replaced by her husband:

“June 2024 took something from me. Something I had spent my entire life building. A band. A business. A family. A name.

My sister wanted her husband to become a member of the band, taking my brother’s place. I made it equally clear that I was not okay with that. By then, the situation had become about far more than the lineup. I had witnessed instability and broken trust that fundamentally changed my ability to move forward.

Weeks later, I was terminated. The day after my birthday.”

He also claims that he asked his sister not to “misrepresent” his support for the lineup changes, appearing to refer to the Rolling Stone interview, while revealing that he lost all “financial interest and access to the resources and business” when he was kicked out of the group.

Perry has continued to speak out on the drama surrounding the (former) family band, and on Halloween, he took another pointed shot at his sister and the new iteration of The Band Perry:

“The Band Perry wins Halloween this year. No costumes needed when my sister and her 2nd husband have spent the whole year cosplaying as our sibling band.

The real horror story? Watching them try to hit family blood harmonies with a marriage certificate.”

He has continued to speak out, very much placing the blame for his departure on his sister, and she has continued to release new music with her husband, most recently putting out holiday EP, A Very Band Perry Christmas, and continuing on with business as usual, pretty much, acting like nothing is really wrong with her relationship with her brother.

They also attended the CMA Awards last night, and during an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Kimberly was asked about all of the drama, and she gave a very PR, pre-rehearsed response, saying that she loves her family “so much,” and she and her husband were super excited to be there celebrating country music.

She also thanked ET for having them, and it was honestly a bizarre answer at the end, which I think says a lot about what’s really going on:

“Just that I love my family so much. I love this band. We’re super excited to be here in season two talking about new music. Thank you so much for just having us and your time. It’s beautiful to be here with everyone this evening.”

When host Cassie DiLaura pressed a little more, bringing up what Dolly Parton’s niece Danielle had just told her about their family drama, Kimberly kind of brushed it off, saying that “everyone will work it out over Thanksgiving”:

“Everyone will work it out over Thanksgiving. It’s right around the corner.”

I HIGHLY doubt anything will be worked out between Kimberly and Neil over Thanksgiving, I’d be shocked if they were going to see each other at all, which is sad, but I think this interview says it all about the state of their relationship right now.

You can watch it here: